Cardio vs Weights vs Both: The Body Composition Showdown

WHAT CARDIO ACTUALLY DOES TO YOUR BODY

Cardio is cardiovascular exercise. Running, cycling, swimming, rowing, elliptical, walking.

When you do cardio, your heart rate increases, you're breathing hard, and you're burning anywhere from 300 to 600 calories per hour depending on intensity. During that workout, your body uses stored carbs and fat for fuel, creating a calorie deficit if you're not eating more to compensate.

But here's what happens after the workout: the calorie burn stops within 30 to 60 minutes. There's minimal afterburn effect, unlike weights. And your hunger increases significantly, which means you'll eat more later. You're also not building any muscle from cardio alone.

Over time, months and years of cardio improves your cardiovascular health and increases your endurance. It burns calories, but it doesn't change your body composition much. If done excessively without strength training, it can actually lead to muscle loss. You become smaller but maintain the same body fat percentage. You're basically a smaller version of yourself.

Let me show you what this looks like with real numbers. Say you start at 150 pounds with 30% body fat. That's 105 pounds of lean mass and 45 pounds of fat. After six months of cardio only, you drop to 130 pounds at 30% body fat. That's 91 pounds lean mass and 39 pounds fat.

You lost 20 pounds total. But 14 pounds was muscle. Only 6 pounds was fat.

You're lighter, sure. But you look soft. No definition. Same body shape, just smaller.

WHAT WEIGHTS ACTUALLY DO TO YOUR BODY

Weights mean resistance training. Lifting dumbbells, barbells, machines, bodyweight exercises.

When you lift weights, you're burning fewer calories during the actual workout compared to cardio, usually 150 to 300 calories per hour. You're creating muscle damage, which sounds bad but is actually good because that's how muscle grows. Your body uses glycogen for fuel, so there's not much fat burning happening during the workout itself.

But here's where it gets interesting. After the workout, your calorie burn continues for 24 to 48 hours. This is called the afterburn effect. Your muscles need to repair, which requires energy. Your metabolism stays elevated. You do get hungrier, but the increase is less dramatic than with cardio.

Over months and years, weights build muscle mass and change your body composition. You have more muscle, less fat. Your resting metabolic rate increases, meaning you burn more calories even while sitting on the couch. You create definition, shape, and tone. You look lean even at the same weight you started at.

Same example. You start at 150 pounds with 30% body fat, 105 pounds lean mass, 45 pounds fat. After six months of weights only with a proper diet, you're at 145 pounds with 20% body fat. That's 116 pounds lean mass and 29 pounds fat.

You only lost 5 pounds on the scale. But you lost 16 pounds of fat and gained 11 pounds of muscle.

You're almost the same weight, but you look completely different. Leaner. More defined. Better shape.

THE HONEST COMPARISON

Let's compare three people with the same goal: lose fat and look lean.

Person A does cardio only. She runs four times per week for 45 minutes each session. She's burning about 400 calories per session, so 1,600 calories burned per week. The scale drops quickly, which feels great. But her body composition barely changes because she's losing muscle and fat proportionally. The result? She's smaller, but still soft. No definition.

Person B does weights only. She lifts four times per week for 45 minutes each session. She burns about 200 calories per session during the workout, so 800 calories burned per week just from lifting. But then there's the afterburn effect, which adds roughly 400 additional calories over the 48 hours after each workout. Her total weekly burn is 800 from workouts plus 1,600 from afterburn, which equals 2,400 calories. The scale drops slowly, which can be frustrating. But her body composition changes dramatically. She's building muscle while losing fat. The result? She's the same weight or slightly lighter, but looks 15 pounds lighter. Defined. Toned. Lean.

Person C does both. She lifts three times per week and does cardio twice per week. She burns 600 from cardio, 600 from lifting, and 1,200 from afterburn, totaling 2,400 calories per week. The scale drops moderately. Body composition improves as she builds some muscle and loses fat. The result? She's leaner and more defined than cardio-only, but doesn't have as much muscle as weights-only. And it takes the most time, over five hours per week in the gym.

The winner for fat loss plus body composition? Weights only. They burn similar total calories when you account for afterburn, build muscle, and create the lean, defined look most people actually want. Cardio burns calories during the workout but doesn't change body composition. Both works, but requires more time commitment for similar results.

WHO CARDIO WORKS FOR

Cardio is the right choice if your primary goal is cardiovascular health. Maybe you want to improve heart health, you're training for a race or endurance event, or you genuinely enjoy running, cycling, or swimming.

It also works if you have a lot of weight to lose and need maximum calorie burn. If you're 50-plus pounds overweight, eating a lot, and need high calorie burn to create a deficit, cardio can help. Or if you're not ready to focus on body composition yet and just want the number on the scale to drop.

Cardio also makes sense if you genuinely enjoy it. If it's your stress relief, if you love it, if you'd do it even if it didn't burn calories, then absolutely keep doing it.

And if you're already lean and muscular, lifting regularly and just want to add cardio for heart health, go for it. You're maintaining muscle and just need some extra calorie burn.

But cardio is not the right choice if your goal is to look toned or defined, if you want to change your body shape, if you're already doing cardio and not seeing results, or if you hate it but force yourself because you think you have to.

WHO WEIGHTS WORK FOR

Weights are the right choice if your goal is to look lean, toned, and defined. If you want visible muscle definition, if you want to change your body shape, if you want curves in the right places like glutes and shoulders, weights are non-negotiable.

They also work if you want to maintain muscle while losing fat. Maybe you're cutting calories and don't want to lose muscle, or you've lost weight before and looked skinny fat, or you want to keep your metabolism high. Weights solve all of that.

If you're short on time and only have three to four hours per week max, weights give you more bang for your buck. You get the afterburn effect plus muscle building in less time than endless cardio sessions.

Weights also provide long-term metabolic benefits. More muscle means higher resting metabolism. You burn more calories 24/7, not just during workouts.

And if you're over 30, you need to know that muscle loss with age, called sarcopenia, starts at 30. Weights prevent this. Cardio doesn't.

Weights aren't the right choice if you're training for an endurance event where you obviously need sport-specific training, if you have joint issues that prevent lifting (though bodyweight and machines often work), or if you absolutely hate resistance training and won't stick to it.

WHO NEEDS BOTH

You need both cardio and weights if you're an athlete who needs strength and endurance for your sport. You need both for performance.

You also might need both if you're significantly overweight and want to preserve muscle. Use cardio for high calorie burn and weights to prevent muscle loss during weight loss.

If you have six-plus hours per week to train, you have time to do both and you enjoy variety, go ahead.

And if you're already lean and want to optimize further, maybe you've built muscle with weights and now want to improve cardiovascular fitness, adding cardio makes sense. You're maintaining, not trying to lose.

But you don't need both if you're short on time. Just pick one based on your goal. You don't need both if you're a beginner. Start with one, add the other later. And you definitely don't need both if you're not enjoying your workouts. Do what you'll actually stick to.

THE HUNGER FACTOR NOBODY TALKS ABOUT

Here's something critical that nobody mentions. Cardio makes you very hungry. It increases appetite hormones significantly. You'll eat back 50 to 70% of the calories you burned.

Example: you burn 400 calories running, then eat 300 extra calories later. Your net deficit is only 100 calories.

Weights create a moderate hunger increase, but it's less dramatic. Your protein requirements increase, which actually keeps you full. Example: you burn 200 calories lifting, eat 100 extra calories later. Your net deficit is 100 calories, but you also get the muscle building bonus.

This is why people do tons of cardio and wonder why they're not losing weight. They're eating back the calories they burned and don't even realize it.

People who lift weights eat more protein which is filling, have less dramatic hunger spikes, and create the same net deficit with way less suffering.

THE BIGGEST MISTAKES PEOPLE MAKE

The first mistake is doing cardio to tone up. Cardio doesn't tone anything. Cardio burns calories. Toning means building muscle plus losing fat, which equals weights plus a calorie deficit.

The second mistake is avoiding weights because you don't want to get bulky. You won't get bulky. Building significant muscle requires years of consistent training, eating in a calorie surplus, high protein intake, and often requires testosterone levels most women don't have. Lifting weights makes you lean and defined, not bulky.

The third mistake is trying to do both and burning out. You try to lift four times per week and run four times per week. You're exhausted, always sore, and quit after six weeks. Better approach? Pick one. Do it consistently. Add the other later if needed.

The fourth mistake is only doing cardio because it burns more calories. Yes, cardio burns 400 calories during the workout. But you're hungry and eat 300 back. Weights burn 200 during plus 200 afterburn which equals 400 total. Less hunger. Plus muscle building.

The fifth mistake is lifting weights but not progressively overloading. You lift the same 10-pound dumbbells for six months. Your body adapts. No more muscle growth. No more changes. You need to progressively increase weight to continue building muscle.

THE REAL TRUTH ABOUT CARDIO VS WEIGHTS

You don't need both to get results.

If your goal is weight loss only, cardio works but so do weights. Pick what you'll stick to.

If your goal is body composition, meaning lean, defined, toned, weights are essential. Cardio is optional.

If your goal is general health and fitness, both are beneficial but weights give you more bang for your buck.

If your goal is an endurance sport, obviously you need cardio for your sport.

For most people, weights should be the priority. Cardio is optional.

You can be lean, defined, and healthy with zero cardio if you lift weights consistently, eat in a slight calorie deficit, walk 8,000-plus steps per day for general movement, and eat enough protein.

Cardio is great for cardiovascular health. But it's not required for fat loss or looking lean.

THE OPTIMAL APPROACH FOR MOST PEOPLE

If you have three hours per week, lift weights three times per week using a full body or upper/lower split. Walk daily for steps and general movement. Skip formal cardio entirely.

If you have four to five hours per week, lift weights three to four times per week and add one to two cardio sessions of 20 to 30 minutes. Walk daily.

If you have six-plus hours per week, lift weights four times per week, do cardio two to three times per week, and walk daily.

If you're a beginner, start with weights only three times per week. Walk for cardio. Add formal cardio later if you want it.

If you hate weights, do cardio but accept that body composition changes will be minimal. Consider bodyweight exercises as a compromise. Walking plus sprints can provide some muscle stimulus.

ONE MORE THING YOU CAN DO THIS WEEK

Don't overhaul your entire training program tomorrow. Just do one thing this week.

If you've been doing cardio only, go to the gym and lift weights for 30 minutes. Just once. Try it. See how you feel. See if you enjoy it.

If you've been doing weights only, keep doing what you're doing. You're on the right path.

If you've been trying to do both and burning out, pick one for the next four weeks. Weights if your goal is body composition. Cardio if your goal is endurance. Focus on one. Master it. Then decide if you want to add the other.

Consistency beats variety. Always.

Here's to building the body you actually want!

Here are product recommendation swaps for the Cardio vs Weights newsletter:

Sarah

P.S. - The single most important thing? Your goal determines your training. Want to look lean and defined? Weights are non-negotiable. Want to run a marathon? Obviously you need to run. Want general health? Either works, pick what you'll stick to. Stop doing what you hate just because someone said you have to. Do what aligns with your actual goal and what you'll do consistently. do consistently.