Foods our grandparents ate that we're scared of now

In partnership with

Good morning Healthy Mail family!

My grandmother lived to 94. She ate butter with every meal, cooked with lard, ate eggs daily, drank whole milk, and never counted a calorie in her life.

Meanwhile, we're here in 2025, terrified of egg yolks, convinced that butter will kill us, and spending extra money on egg whites in a carton.

What changed? Not the science of nutrition - but the marketing of fear.

The Foods We're Unnecessarily Afraid Of:

1. Butter

What our grandparents did: Spread it on toast, cooked with it, ate it without a second thought

What we do now: Buy dairy-free spreads with 15 ingredients we can't pronounce, convinced butter will clog our arteries

The science: Research has debunked the saturated fat-heart disease connection. Butter contains vitamins A, D, E, and K2 (crucial for bone health), plus butyrate which supports gut health.

The reality: Grass-fed butter is a whole food. Margarine and "buttery spreads" are ultra-processed industrial products.

The irony: We replaced natural butter with trans fats, which actually DO harm cardiovascular health, then had to ban trans fats decades later.

2. Whole Milk

What our grandparents did: Drank it straight from glass bottles delivered to their doorstep

What we do now: Buy skim milk, convinced fat is the enemy, or spend $8 on oat milk with added oils and sugar

The science: Full-fat dairy is associated with LOWER obesity risk in multiple studies. The fat helps you absorb fat-soluble vitamins and increases satiety.

The research: Countries with higher full-fat dairy consumption often have lower rates of heart disease.

The comparison: Skim milk has more sugar concentration, less satiety, and requires fortification to replace the removed fat-soluble vitamins.

3. Egg Yolks

What our grandparents did: Ate 2-3 eggs for breakfast regularly, yolks included

What we do now: Order egg white omelets, buy cartons of egg whites, throw away the most nutritious part

The science: Dietary cholesterol has minimal impact on blood cholesterol for most people. The yolk contains virtually all the egg's nutrients - choline, vitamin D, B vitamins, and antioxidants.

The research: Studies show eating whole eggs improves HDL cholesterol (the "good" kind) and doesn't increase heart disease risk.

The waste: Throwing away yolks means discarding 90% of the egg's nutrition to save 50 calories.

4. Potatoes

What our grandparents did: Ate them regularly - mashed, baked, roasted

What we do now: Avoid them because "carbs are bad" and spend money on cauliflower substitutes

The science: Potatoes are packed with potassium, vitamin C, and resistant starch (when cooled). They're one of the most satiating foods.

The research: Blue zones (populations with longest life expectancy) consume potatoes regularly.

The confusion: French fries and potato chips are problematic. Plain potatoes are not.

5. Lard and Animal Fats

What our grandparents did: Cooked with lard, saved bacon grease, used tallow

What we do now: Use seed oils and vegetable shortening, thinking they're healthier

The science: Traditional animal fats are stable at high heat (unlike many vegetable oils) and contain fat-soluble vitamins.

The history: Vegetable oil companies ran massive campaigns to demonize animal fats and promote their products as "heart healthy."

The irony: We replaced stable, traditional fats with highly processed industrial oils that may actually increase inflammation.

6. Organ Meats

What our grandparents did: Ate liver, heart, kidneys regularly - "nose to tail" eating

What we do now: Find organ meats disgusting, pay for multivitamins instead

The science: Liver is one of the most nutrient-dense foods on earth - loaded with vitamin A, iron, B vitamins, and copper.

The comparison: 3 oz of liver provides more nutrients than most multivitamins.

The cultural shift: We went from honoring the whole animal to eating only muscle meat and throwing away the most nutritious parts.

7. White Rice

What our grandparents did: Ate white rice regularly, especially in Asian and Mediterranean cultures with excellent longevity

What we do now: Convinced it's "bad carbs," replaced with cauliflower rice or expensive alternatives

The science: White rice is easily digestible, provides quick energy, and doesn't spike blood sugar as dramatically as many processed "health" foods.

The context: Billions of healthy, long-lived people around the world eat white rice daily.

The reality: It's a simple, affordable carbohydrate source. The problem isn't the rice - it's eating it in isolation without protein or vegetables.

8. Bread

What our grandparents did: Ate freshly baked bread daily, often homemade

What we do now: Terrified of gluten, carbs, and bread in general (unless it's gluten-free with 20 ingredients)

The science: For people without celiac disease or diagnosed gluten sensitivity (about 1% and 6% of the population respectively), wheat isn't inherently problematic.

The real issue: Modern commercial bread is ultra-processed with additives. Traditional sourdough or simple homemade bread is completely different.

The confusion: Gluten-free doesn't mean healthier. Gluten-free processed foods are still processed foods.

Why We Became Afraid:

The diet industry profits from fear. Every decade needs a new villain: fat, then carbs, then sugar, then gluten. Fear sells products.

Correlation was confused with causation. Heart disease increased alongside processed food consumption, but we blamed traditional foods that were always in the diet.

Nuance doesn't sell. "Eat whole foods, mostly plants, not too much" doesn't create billion-dollar industries. Fear-based elimination does.

We forgot traditional preparation methods. Our grandparents soaked beans, fermented dairy, made bone broth - techniques that increased digestibility and nutrition.

Marketing replaced wisdom. Food corporations convinced us their new products were superior to foods humans had eaten for millennia.

What Our Grandparents Got Right:

They ate real food. Ingredients they could see and recognize, not laboratory creations.

They cooked at home. Most meals were prepared from scratch, not reheated from packages.

They ate seasonal and local. Fresh produce when available, preserved foods in winter.

They used the whole animal/plant. Nothing wasted, everything utilized.

They didn't obsess. Food was nourishment and pleasure, not a source of anxiety and moral judgment.

They moved naturally. Daily activity was built into life, not something requiring gym memberships.

The Modern Paradox:

We have more "health information" than ever and are sicker than previous generations.

We spend billions on supplements while avoiding nutrient-dense whole foods our ancestors thrived on.

We trust processed "health foods" more than traditional foods with thousands of years of safe consumption.

What Actually Matters:

Looking for unbiased, fact-based news? Join 1440 today.

Join over 4 million Americans who start their day with 1440 – your daily digest for unbiased, fact-centric news. From politics to sports, we cover it all by analyzing over 100 sources. Our concise, 5-minute read lands in your inbox each morning at no cost. Experience news without the noise; let 1440 help you make up your own mind. Sign up now and invite your friends and family to be part of the informed.

Subscribe to 1440 today.

The source and quality of food matters more than the specific food. Pastured eggs are different from factory-farmed eggs. Grass-fed butter is different from conventional butter.

Processing level matters. A baked potato is different from potato chips, even though both are "potatoes."

Context matters. White rice with vegetables and protein is different from white rice alone.

Your individual response matters. Some people genuinely don't tolerate certain foods. But that's different from declaring foods universally "bad."

The Bottom Line:

Your great-grandmother probably had a better intuitive understanding of nutrition than most modern "wellness experts."

She didn't need apps, trackers, or complicated rules. She ate real food, mostly prepared at home, in reasonable portions, without anxiety.

Maybe instead of looking for the next trendy superfood or elimination diet, we should look backward at what sustained healthy humans for generations.

The Practical Approach:

You don't need to eat exactly like your grandparents, but you can adopt their principles:

• Choose whole foods over processed alternatives

• Don't fear traditional foods that have nourished humans for centuries

• Cook at home most of the time

• Eat reasonable portions without obsession

• Stop letting marketing create fear around normal foods

Starting Your Day the Old-Fashioned Way:

One place where we've really lost touch with traditional wisdom is breakfast. Our grandparents ate eggs, oatmeal, toast with butter - simple, satisfying foods that fueled their mornings.

Now we grab protein bars with 20 ingredients or skip breakfast entirely because we're "intermittent fasting."

The truth? A real breakfast made with whole foods sets the tone for your entire day. Stable blood sugar from the start means fewer cravings, better energy, and clearer thinking.

My breakfast collection includes 30 recipes built on these traditional principles - eggs, oats, whole grains, real butter, whole milk - simple ingredients our grandparents would recognize, prepared in ways that fit modern schedules.

Get 30 Healthy Breakfasts - CODE: BREAKFAST for 50% off

No fear-based elimination, no exotic superfoods, no complicated rules. Just real food that nourishes your body the way breakfast should.

What food are you unnecessarily afraid of that your grandparents ate freely? Hit reply and tell me!

Here's to learning from the wisdom of previous generations! Sarah

P.S. - My grandmother's secret to longevity when I asked her? "I ate food, not too much, and I didn't worry about it." Sometimes the simplest advice is the best.