• Healthy Mail
  • Posts
  • Why protein is the most important nutrient for women

Why protein is the most important nutrient for women

What your low-calorie, low-protein diet is actually doing to your body...

Good morning Healthy Mail family!

Let me tell you about two women I know who both wanted to lose weight.

Woman A: Ate 1,200 calories daily. Mostly salads, fruit, rice cakes, low-fat yogurt. Protein intake: 40-50g daily. Lost 15 pounds in 3 months.

One year later: Gained back 20 pounds. Constantly tired. Hair thinning. Always cold. Weak. Hungry all the time. Looks softer and less toned than before she started.

Woman B: Ate 1,800 calories daily. Every meal had protein - eggs, chicken, fish, Greek yogurt, beans. Protein intake: 120-140g daily. Lost 12 pounds in 3 months.

One year later: Still lean. Maintained the weight loss. Strong. High energy. Hair and nails growing like crazy. Looks more toned than ever. Not constantly thinking about food.

Same goal. Completely different approach. Completely different results.

Here's what drives me crazy: The diet industry has convinced women that eating less is the answer. Salads. Smoothies. "Light" meals. Low-calorie everything.

Meanwhile, you're starving. You're weak. You're losing muscle. Your metabolism is slowing down. Your hair is falling out. You're irritable and exhausted.

And nobody's telling you the real problem: You're not eating enough protein.

Protein isn't just for bodybuilders and men trying to get huge. It's literally the most important nutrient for women's health, weight management, hormones, metabolism, and aging well.

Today I'm breaking down why protein matters more than any other nutrient, what happens when you don't get enough, and how much you actually need.

WHAT PROTEIN ACTUALLY DOES IN YOUR BODY

Protein isn't just one thing. It's the building block for almost everything in your body.

Protein builds and repairs:

  • Muscle tissue (obviously)

  • Skin, hair, and nails

  • Organs (heart, liver, kidneys, brain)

  • Bones

  • Blood cells

  • Immune system components

  • Enzymes and hormones

Without adequate protein, your body literally can't:

  • Maintain muscle mass

  • Keep your metabolism running properly

  • Regulate hormones

  • Fight off infections

  • Heal wounds

  • Grow strong hair and nails

  • Keep your skin firm and elastic

Here's what people don't understand:

Your body doesn't store protein like it stores fat or carbs. There's no "protein reserve" to pull from when you don't eat enough.

So when you eat low protein, your body has to break down your own tissues to get the amino acids it needs.

It breaks down: Your muscle. Your hair. Your skin. Your organs if things get extreme enough.

This is why women on low-protein diets lose hair, get weak, age faster, and gain back all the weight they lost.

WHY WOMEN SPECIFICALLY NEED MORE PROTEIN THAN THEY'RE GETTING

Women face unique challenges that make protein even more critical:

1. Women naturally have less muscle mass than men

Men have 40-50% more muscle mass than women naturally. This means women need to work harder to build and maintain muscle.

Less muscle = slower metabolism = easier to gain weight and harder to lose it

The solution? Adequate protein + strength training.

2. Women lose muscle faster during dieting

When you're in a calorie deficit (eating less to lose weight), your body needs fuel. It can get that fuel from fat stores OR from breaking down muscle.

Studies show women lose proportionally more muscle during dieting than men if protein intake isn't high enough.

High protein during dieting tells your body: "Keep the muscle, burn the fat instead."

Low protein during dieting tells your body: "No reason to keep this expensive muscle tissue, break it down for energy."

3. Hormonal fluctuations increase protein needs

Women's hormones fluctuate throughout the month. During the luteal phase (second half of cycle), metabolism speeds up and protein needs increase.

During pregnancy and breastfeeding, protein needs skyrocket.

During perimenopause and menopause, estrogen drops and muscle loss accelerates unless protein intake is high.

4. Women are sold "diet foods" that are low in protein

The foods marketed to women are almost always low-protein:

  • Smoothies and smoothie bowls (15g protein at best)

  • Large salads with minimal protein (10g protein)

  • Fruit and yogurt parfaits (8g protein)

  • Oatmeal with berries (6g protein)

  • Rice cakes and hummus (4g protein)

Meanwhile, the foods marketed to men:

  • Steak and potatoes (40g+ protein)

  • Burgers (30g+ protein)

  • Chicken and rice (35g+ protein)

Women are taught to eat "light" while men eat "hearty." This creates a massive protein gap.

WHY PROTEIN IS KEY FOR WEIGHT LOSS

If you want to lose weight and keep it off, protein is non-negotiable.

1. Protein keeps you full longer

Protein is the most satiating macronutrient. It triggers release of satiety hormones (peptide YY, GLP-1) that tell your brain "we're satisfied, stop eating."

Study: People who eat high-protein breakfasts (30g+) consume 135 fewer calories at lunch without trying.

Another study: Increasing protein from 15% to 30% of calories led to eating 441 fewer calories daily without consciously restricting.

You naturally eat less when you eat more protein because you're actually satisfied.

2. Protein preserves muscle during weight loss

When you're in a calorie deficit, your body needs energy. It can get it from fat OR from breaking down muscle.

Low protein diet during deficit: Lose fat AND muscle. End result = slower metabolism, "skinny fat" appearance, weight regain.

High protein diet during deficit: Lose primarily fat, preserve muscle. End result = leaner appearance, maintained metabolism, keep the weight off.

Study: Two groups ate the same calories to lose weight. Group A ate 0.8g protein per pound bodyweight. Group B ate 0.4g per pound.

Both lost 20 pounds. But:

  • Group A: 18 pounds fat, 2 pounds muscle

  • Group B: 12 pounds fat, 8 pounds muscle

Same weight loss on scale. Completely different body composition.

3. Protein burns more calories to digest

Your body burns calories digesting food. This is called the thermic effect of food (TEF).

  • Protein: 20-30% of calories burned during digestion

  • Carbs: 5-10% of calories burned

  • Fat: 0-3% of calories burned

Example: You eat 100 calories of protein. Your body burns 25 calories just digesting it. Net calories absorbed: 75.

You eat 100 calories of fat. Your body burns 2 calories digesting it. Net calories absorbed: 98.

Over time, this adds up. Eating 120g protein daily burns an extra 100-120 calories compared to eating 50g protein.

4. Protein prevents metabolism from crashing

When you diet, your metabolism naturally slows down. This is your body adapting to lower calorie intake.

But the metabolism drop is much smaller when protein intake is high because you're preserving muscle (muscle burns calories at rest).

Low protein diet: Metabolism drops 20-30% High protein diet: Metabolism drops 5-10%

This is why people gain weight back after crash diets. Their metabolism crashed along with their muscle mass.

HOW MUCH PROTEIN DO WOMEN ACTUALLY NEED?

The RDA (Recommended Daily Allowance) for protein is 0.36g per pound of bodyweight.

For a 150-pound woman, that's 54g protein daily.

This is the bare minimum to prevent deficiency. It's not optimal for:

  • Weight loss

  • Muscle building or maintenance

  • Aging well

  • Athletic performance

  • Hormone health

Optimal protein intake for most women:

For weight maintenance: 0.8-1.0g per pound of bodyweight

  • 150-pound woman = 120-150g protein daily

For weight loss: 1.0-1.2g per pound of bodyweight

  • 150-pound woman = 150-180g protein daily

  • Higher protein during calorie deficit preserves muscle better

For muscle building: 1.0-1.2g per pound of bodyweight

  • Same as weight loss targets

  • Combined with strength training

For women over 40: 1.0-1.2g per pound of bodyweight

  • Muscle loss accelerates with age

  • Higher protein prevents age-related muscle loss (sarcopenia)

"But won't all that protein damage my kidneys?"

No. This myth needs to die.

High protein only affects people with pre-existing kidney disease. For healthy people, high protein intake is perfectly safe.

Study: People ate 1.2g protein per pound bodyweight for 2 years. No negative effects on kidney function.

Your kidneys are designed to filter protein. Unless you have kidney disease, protein intake isn't a concern.

WHAT 120G PROTEIN ACTUALLY LOOKS LIKE IN A DAY

Most women I talk to think 120g protein is impossible to reach. It's not. You just need to prioritize it.

REALISTIC 120G PROTEIN DAY:

Breakfast (25-30g):

  • 3 eggs + 2 slices toast = 24g

  • OR Greek yogurt parfait with protein powder = 35g

  • OR protein smoothie = 30g

Lunch (30-35g):

  • 6 oz chicken or fish = 35-40g

  • OR 1 cup cottage cheese + veggies = 28g

  • OR Large salad with 5 oz protein = 30g

Snack (15-20g):

  • Greek yogurt = 15-20g

  • OR Protein bar = 15-20g

  • OR 2 hard-boiled eggs = 12g

Dinner (30-40g):

  • 6 oz protein (chicken, fish, beef, turkey) = 35-45g

Optional evening snack (10g):

  • String cheese = 7g

  • OR Small Greek yogurt = 10g

Total: 110-135g protein

THE PROTEIN-PER-MEAL STRATEGY

Instead of tracking total daily protein, aim for protein targets at each meal:

Breakfast: 25-30g Lunch: 30-35g Dinner: 30-35g Snacks: 15-20g total

Hit these targets and you'll automatically get 100-120g daily.

HIGH-PROTEIN FOODS FOR WOMEN

Animal proteins (highest protein per calorie):

  • Chicken breast: 31g protein per 4 oz (140 cal)

  • Turkey breast: 34g protein per 4 oz (120 cal)

  • White fish (cod, tilapia): 28g protein per 4 oz (110 cal)

  • Salmon: 25g protein per 4 oz (200 cal)

  • Shrimp: 24g protein per 4 oz (120 cal)

  • Eggs: 6g protein per egg (70 cal)

  • Greek yogurt: 15-20g protein per cup (100-140 cal)

  • Cottage cheese: 14g protein per 1/2 cup (90 cal)

Plant proteins:

  • Lentils: 18g protein per cup cooked (230 cal)

  • Chickpeas: 15g protein per cup cooked (270 cal)

  • Black beans: 15g protein per cup cooked (225 cal)

  • Tofu: 20g protein per cup (180 cal)

  • Tempeh: 31g protein per cup (320 cal)

  • Edamame: 17g protein per cup (190 cal)

Protein supplements:

  • Whey protein: 20-25g per scoop (100-120 cal)

  • Plant protein powder: 20g per scoop (110-130 cal)

  • Collagen peptides: 18g per scoop (70 cal)

WHY WOMEN AVOID PROTEIN (AND WHY THEY'RE WRONG)

Myth #1: "Protein will make me bulky"

No. Building significant muscle requires:

  • Years of consistent heavy lifting

  • Calorie surplus

  • Often specific training programs

Eating adequate protein while in a calorie deficit or maintenance makes you lean and toned, not bulky.

Women don't have enough testosterone to "accidentally" get bulky.

Myth #2: "Protein is expensive"

Compared to what?

  • Rotisserie chicken: $6, provides 4 meals of protein = $1.50 per meal

  • Eggs: $6/dozen organic = $0.50 per egg, 3 eggs = $1.50 for 18g protein

  • Canned tuna: $1.50 per can, 25g protein

  • Greek yogurt: $1.50 per cup, 20g protein

  • Beans: $1 per can, 15g protein

Compare to:

  • Takeout lunch: $12-15

  • Starbucks latte and muffin: $8

  • Salad from salad bar: $12 (with minimal protein)

Protein is cheap. Convenience is expensive.

Myth #3: "I'm not hungry enough to eat that much protein"

You're not hungry because you're not eating enough protein.

It's a cycle:

  • Low protein → constant hunger → eat more carbs and fat trying to feel full → still hungry → repeat

High protein → satisfied → naturally eat less overall → not constantly hungry

Try hitting 120g protein daily for one week. Your appetite will regulate itself.

PROTEIN FOR WOMEN OVER 40

This is critical: Women over 40 need MORE protein, not less.

Why:

Muscle loss accelerates after 40. You naturally lose 3-8% of muscle mass per decade after 30, accelerating after 40.

Estrogen drops during perimenopause/menopause. Estrogen helps maintain muscle. When it drops, you lose muscle faster unless protein intake is high.

Bone density decreases. Osteoporosis risk increases. Protein is essential for bone health (bones are made of protein matrix with calcium).

Metabolism slows. Less muscle = slower metabolism = easier to gain weight.

Women over 40 should aim for 1.0-1.2g protein per pound bodyweight MINIMUM.

This, combined with strength training 3x weekly, prevents age-related muscle loss and keeps metabolism high.

ONE MORE THING YOU CAN DO TODAY

Track your protein intake for just one day. Don't change what you eat, just write down everything and add up the protein.

Most women are shocked to discover they're eating 40-60g protein daily when they need 100-130g.

You can't fix what you don't measure.

Track one day. See where you actually are. Then aim to add 10-15g protein to each meal starting tomorrow.

Breakfast: Add 2 eggs or Greek yogurt Lunch: Double the protein portion Dinner: Add palm-sized portion of protein

This simple change will get you from 50g to 100g daily.

THE MISSING PIECE

You now understand why protein is critical for women - weight loss, muscle maintenance, hormone health, aging well, metabolism.

But here's what I hear: "I know I need more protein at breakfast, but I don't know what high-protein breakfasts to actually make besides eggs."

That's the gap. You understand the concept but need practical breakfast options.

My 30 Healthy Breakfasts collection solves this:

Every recipe has 25-35g protein (hits your morning target)
Options beyond eggs (Greek yogurt bowls, protein pancakes, breakfast burritos, smoothies)
Quick options (5 minutes) and weekend options (20 minutes)
Keeps you full until lunch (no more 10am snacking)

Start your day with 25-30g protein and everything else gets easier. Cravings disappear. Energy stabilizes. You naturally eat less throughout the day.

Fix breakfast, fix everything.

Here's to eating enough protein! Sarah

P.S. - The single most important meal for protein? Breakfast. Get 25-30g protein at breakfast and it eliminates mid-morning cravings, stabilizes your blood sugar all day, and sets you up to hit your protein target. Start there tomorrow morning.