Why You Can't Stick to Anything: The Habit Formation Guide

In partnership with

Stay One Scoop Ahead of the New Year

The new year is the perfect time to build healthy habits that actually stick. AG1 helps you stay one scoop ahead of the new year by supporting energy, gut health, and filling common nutrient gaps, all with a simple daily routine.

Instead of chasing resolutions that are hard to maintain, AG1 makes health easier. Just one scoop each morning supports digestive regularity, immune defense, and energy levels, making it one of the most effortless habits to keep all year long. A fresh year brings fresh momentum, and small daily habits can make a meaningful difference.

Start your mornings with AG1, the daily health drink with 75+ ingredients, including 5 probiotic strains, designed to replace a multivitamin, probiotics, and more, all in one scoop.

For a limited time only, get a FREE AG1 duffel bag and FREE AG1 Welcome Kit with your first AG1 subscription! Only while supplies last. Get started today.

Start One Simple Habit

WHY WILLPOWER DOESN'T WORK

Here's the uncomfortable truth: Willpower is a limited resource.

In the morning, you have high willpower. You resist the donuts at work. You pack your healthy lunch. You're disciplined. But by afternoon, your willpower is depleting. You're tired. Stressed. Someone offers you candy and you say yes. By evening, your willpower is completely gone. You planned to work out but skip it. You planned to cook but order takeout instead.

You made 100 food decisions today. You only had enough willpower for 60 of them.

This is called decision fatigue. Every single decision you make depletes your willpower tank, and by evening the tank is empty. You default to whatever's easiest.

This is why you eat healthy all day then binge at night. Why you work out Monday through Wednesday then quit by Thursday. Why you meal prep once then never again.

You're not lazy. You're depleted.

The solution isn't more willpower. It's eliminating the need for willpower entirely.

THE REAL REASON YOU CAN'T STICK TO ANYTHING

You're trying to change too much at once.

Most people do this in January: "Starting Monday, I'm going to meal prep every Sunday, work out 5 times per week, track all my food in an app, drink 100 ounces of water daily, get 8 hours of sleep, meditate for 10 minutes, and walk 10,000 steps."

That's 7 new habits. Simultaneously. Starting Monday.

Week 1, you white-knuckle through everything. You're exhausted but succeeding. Week 2, one thing slips, usually meal prep because it takes the most time. Week 3, the slip becomes a crack and now two things are slipping. Week 4, everything crumbles and you're back to zero habits.

You think you failed because you lack discipline. The truth? You tried to change too much at once.

Research shows you have an 80% chance of maintaining one new habit. You have a 35% chance of maintaining two new habits simultaneously. You have less than 10% chance of maintaining three or more.

You're not weak. You're human. Your brain can only handle one major behavior change at a time.

THE HABIT FORMATION SCIENCE

Habits form through a neurological loop: cue, routine, reward.

Think about checking your phone. The cue is your phone buzzing or you're bored. The routine is picking up your phone and scrolling social media. The reward is the dopamine hit from new content. You've done this 10,000-plus times. It's automatic. You don't think about it. You just do it. This is a habit.

Or think about eating chips while watching TV. The cue is sitting on the couch and turning on the TV. The routine is walking to the pantry, grabbing chips, eating the entire bag. The reward is taste, distraction, comfort. You've paired TV with chips hundreds of times. Now you can't watch TV without wanting chips. This is a habit.

Your brain doesn't distinguish between good and bad habits. It just repeats patterns that have been reinforced.

To build new habits, you need to create a clear cue, make the routine easy, provide an immediate reward, and repeat until automatic. And by the way, that 21-days myth? It's completely wrong. Research shows it actually takes 66 days on average for a habit to become automatic.

WHY YOUR PAST ATTEMPTS FAILED

Your first failure was relying on motivation. You said "I'm so motivated! Starting tomorrow, everything changes!" But motivation lasted 2 weeks. Then life got hard. Motivation disappeared. Habits died. The fix? Motivation starts habits, but systems maintain them. You need systems, not motivation.

Your second failure was making it too hard. You said "I'm going to meal prep 15 meals every Sunday for 3 hours!" You did it once. Got exhausted. Never again. The fix? Make it so easy you can't say no. "I'm going to cook 2 chicken breasts on Sunday." That's it. Build from there.

Your third failure was having no cue. You said "I'm going to work out 5 times per week!" But you had no specific plan. "I'll go when I have time." You never had time. The fix? Tie it to a specific cue. "After I drop the kids at school, I go straight to the gym." The cue of dropping kids off triggers the routine of going to the gym.

Your fourth failure was focusing on outcomes instead of identity. You said "I want to lose 20 pounds." You lost 5 pounds. Plateaued. Gave up. The fix? "I'm becoming the type of person who works out." Focus on identity, not outcomes. Identity-based habits stick forever.

Your fifth failure was having no accountability or tracking. You said "I'm going to eat healthy!" But you had no tracking. No idea if you're actually doing it. You slowly slipped back to old habits. The fix? Track the behavior. Daily. A checkbox on a calendar. Seeing a streak motivates you to continue.

THE HABIT FORMATION PROTOCOL THAT ACTUALLY WORKS

Step 1 is picking one habit. Not three. Not five. 

ONE. Ask yourself: "What single habit, if I did it consistently for 3 months, would have the biggest impact?" Maybe it's drinking 64 ounces of water daily. Maybe it's walking 8,000 steps daily. Maybe it's eating 100 grams of protein daily, working out 3 times per week, or meal prepping protein on Sunday. Pick one. Commit to that one for 90 days before adding another.

Step 2 is making it so easy you can't fail.

Your habit should take less than 2 minutes to start. Instead of "work out for 60 minutes," make your habit "put on workout clothes." You're not trying to work out for an hour. You're just trying to put on workout clothes. Once they're on, you'll probably work out. But even if you don't, you succeeded at your habit. Instead of "meal prep 15 meals on Sunday," make your habit "cook 2 chicken breasts on Sunday." Lower the bar. Make it laughably easy. Build momentum.

Step 3 is stacking it on an existing habit. 

This is called habit stacking. Tie your new habit to something you already do automatically. The formula is: After I do this current habit, I will do this new habit. For example: "After I pour my morning coffee, I will drink 16 ounces of water." "After I brush my teeth at night, I will lay out my workout clothes." "After I sit down for lunch, I will eat my protein first." "After I put my kids to bed, I will prep tomorrow's lunch." The existing habit becomes the cue for the new habit.

Step 4 is designing your environment. 

Make good habits obvious and easy. Make bad habits invisible and hard. Say you want to eat more protein. Make it obvious by putting protein powder on the counter instead of in the pantry, pre-cooking chicken and putting it in clear containers at eye level in the fridge, buying pre-made hard-boiled eggs. Make junk food invisible by putting chips in the back of the pantry or not buying them at all, keeping no candy on your desk. Say you want to work out in the morning. Make it easy by laying out workout clothes the night before, putting your shoes by the door, setting your alarm across the room so you have to get up. Make sleeping in hard by keeping no phone in the bedroom so you can't hit snooze 5 times. You don't need willpower if your environment is designed correctly.

Step 5 is tracking it daily. Get a calendar, physical or digital.

Mark an X every day you do the habit. This works because you see your streak building which is motivating, you don't want to break the streak which creates accountability, and you have proof you're changing which is reinforcing. The rule is simple: don't break the streak two days in a row. Missed one day? Fine. Life happens. Get back on it tomorrow. Missed two days in a row? Your habit is dying. Rescue it immediately.

Step 6 is focusing on identity instead of outcomes. 

Outcome-based thinking says "I want to lose 20 pounds." Identity-based thinking says "I'm becoming a healthy person." Identity wins because with outcome-based thinking, you hit your goal, lose 20 pounds, then what? You stop. You regain the weight. With identity-based thinking, you're building an identity. "Healthy people work out. I'm a healthy person. Therefore, I work out." This lasts forever. Don't say "I'm trying to eat healthy." Say "I'm a person who eats healthy." Don't say "I want to work out more." Say "I'm an athlete." Don't say "I should drink water." Say "I'm a hydrated person." Your actions follow your identity. Change your identity, and your actions follow.

Step 7 is giving yourself immediate rewards. 

Your brain needs immediate feedback. The problem with healthy habits is they have delayed rewards. You work out today, feel sore tomorrow, see results in 3 months. You meal prep today, get convenience this week, save money this month, get health benefits in years. Your brain doesn't wait 3 months for rewards. It wants rewards now. So create immediate rewards. After your workout, check a box on your calendar for immediate satisfaction. After meal prepping, enjoy your favorite show guilt-free as a reward. After drinking 64 ounces of water, treat yourself to coffee as a reward. Pair the hard thing with something immediately enjoyable.

THE BIGGEST MISTAKES PEOPLE MAKE

The first mistake is trying to build too many habits at once. You can't overhaul your entire life in one month. Pick one. Master it. Then add another.

The second mistake is starting too big. "I'm going to work out 90 minutes every day!" No. Start with 10 minutes 3 times per week. Build from there.

The third mistake is waiting for motivation. Motivation is fleeting. Systems are forever. Build systems that work whether you feel motivated or not.

The fourth mistake is not tracking. If you don't track it, it doesn't exist. Use a calendar. Check the box. Watch the streak grow.

The fifth mistake is giving up after one slip. Missed one day? Fine. Don't miss two. One slip is human. Two slips is the beginning of quitting.

The sixth mistake is focusing on the goal instead of the system. Goals are good for direction. Systems are good for progress. Focus on showing up, not on outcomes.

THE REAL TRUTH ABOUT STICKING TO THINGS

You don't need more discipline. You need better systems.

Stop relying on willpower that runs out, motivation that's temporary, and big ambitious goals that overwhelm you.

Start building clear cues that tell you when to act, easy starts that are so simple you can't say no, environment design that makes good choices automatic, daily tracking that gives you proof you're changing, and identity shifts that turn you into the person who does this thing.

You don't fail because you're weak. You fail because you're trying to change everything at once using willpower alone.

Pick one habit. Build the system. Make it automatic. Then add the next one.

This is how you actually change. Slowly. Systematically. Permanently.

ONE MORE THING YOU CAN DO THIS WEEK

Don't try to build 5 new habits tomorrow.

Just do one thing this week: Pick your one habit and write it down.

"For the next 90 days, I will [HABIT] after [CUE]."

Examples: "For the next 90 days, I will drink 16 ounces of water after I pour my morning coffee." "For the next 90 days, I will put on my workout clothes after I drop the kids at school." "For the next 90 days, I will eat protein first at every meal after I sit down to eat."

Pick one. Make it easy. Tie it to a cue you already do.

Start tomorrow. Track it on a calendar. Don't break the streak.

In 90 days, you'll have one automatic habit. Then you can add another.

This is how you build a completely different life. One small habit at a time.

Here's to systems that work!

Sarah

P.S. - The single most important thing? You don't need to change everything at once. You need to change one thing and make it stick. One habit, built over 90 days, will do more for you than 10 habits you abandon in 2 weeks. Start small. Be patient. Trust the system. And if that one habit is meal prep, the Bundle gives you the exact system to make it stick forever.